
Raina Avramova and Eng. Dimitar Andreev alerted the Supreme Bar Council with a request to refer the matter to the Constitutional Court
The creation, provided for in the Legal Aid Act, of an information system for recording legal aid electronically for all bar councils solely by the National Legal Aid Bureau contradicts the Constitution. This opinion is expressed by the Sofia attorney Raina Avramova and Eng. Dimitar Andreev - manager of the company "BISOFT" EOOD, who have alerted the Supreme Bar Council (SBC) with a request to refer the matter to the Constitutional Court. Attorney Avramova and Eng. Andreev recall that the provision of Art. 18(4) of the Constitution provides for the possibility of establishing by law a state monopoly over a few exhaustively listed spheres of socio-economic relations, namely - rail transport, national postal and telecommunications networks, the use of nuclear energy, the production of radioactive products, weapons, explosives and biologically potent substances. Neither the activity of creating information systems as a whole, nor separate parts of them, are mentioned in the constitutional provision. A state monopoly is a situation in which, by law, the exclusive right to carry out a certain type of economic activity is granted only to state enterprises. According to them, however, in this case Art. 8a of the Legal Aid Act introduces a de facto monopoly position over the creation of an information system for recording legal aid electronically by all bar councils. "The provision of Art. 18(4) of the Constitution is an exception to the general principle of free economic initiative provided for in Art. 19(1) and to the principle of guaranteeing equal legal conditions for economic activity to all citizens and legal entities provided for in Art. 19(2) of the Constitution. Art. 18(4) of the Constitution cannot be interpreted extensively. The legislator has no power, beyond the exhaustively listed hypotheses in the provision, to grant an exclusive right to carry out economic activity to a specific state legal entity," Attorney Avramova and Eng. Andreev write to the SBC. "Therefore, through the general rule of Art. 8a of the Legal Aid Act, further developed in paragraph 13 of the TFP of the Act Amending the Legal Aid Act, according to which the state legal entity "National Legal Aid Bureau" remains the only legal entity that can create an information system for recording legal aid electronically, the legislator has created an unconstitutional legal situation of a complete state monopoly in an area that does not fall within the scope of Art. 18(4) of the Constitution," they also say. According to Attorney Avramova and Eng. Andreev, moreover, giving the National Legal Aid Bureau the opportunity to become a monopolist in building the information system restricts the right to economic activity, treats investors in the different types of information systems unequally and contradicts the principles of the rule of law and a number of other provisions of the Constitution. "The Bulgarian legal profession is called upon to defend the rights and legitimate interests of citizens and legal entities by virtue of Art. 134 of the Constitution. As its body, the Supreme Bar Council is in turn empowered by Art. 150(4) of the Constitution to refer to the Constitutional Court a request to exercise its constitutional power under Art. 149(1), item 2 to rule on the unconstitutionality of a law that affects the rights and legitimate interests of citizens. The contested provisions bar any legal entity, except the state in the person of the "National Legal Aid Bureau", from creating an information system for recording legal aid electronically, and prevent the bar councils from carrying out their activity of recording legal aid electronically within their autonomy, independence and self-government," they also write to the SBC. You can view the whole article here: Attorney and businessman: The possibility of building an information system for recording legal aid electronically solely by the Legal Aid Bureau contradicts the Constitution






